Which of Red Butler's shoes are more common, plain or star?

[Radiant Bridge]

I know that one version of Red Butler is rare regarding his shoes, but am unsure if the shoes are plain or the star ones in this case. First I heard that the star shoes were the uncommon variant, then I read that the plain shoes were used in the original molds and discontinued shortly after. Can anyone tell me which way it was?

[Tom-sprite]

I think plain is more common but I am not 100 % sure ... I have the doll with the plain version ! ;-)

[Radiant Bridge]

Thank you for responding anyway.

[Allison]

Actually Tom, you have the rarer version. Unlike Rainbow and Patty, star shoe Red is much more common than the plain version. I have both and it took me awhile to find one in good condition with the plain shoes.

[Tom-sprite]

@Allison :

I really wasn t sure about that...thanks for letting me know Allison ! ;-)